Sarah Witherow may have been the Sarah Witherow recorded in the 1860 census of Cumberland Township, Adams County, Pennsylvania. The census listed her as 23 years old and born in Pennsylvania, in dwelling 488, family 545, the household of farmer W. W. Witherow. A published family history states that Sarah Witherow was twice married, but the records does not confirm her maiden name, second marriage, cemetery, or later residence.
Age in 1860: 23
Sex: F
Race: W
Birthplace: Pennsylvania
Township: Cumberland
Dwelling Number: 488
Family Number: 545
Spouse: W. W. Witherow
Identification Status: Possible
Confidence Level: Possible
Evidence Strength: Moderate Circumstantial