Isaiah Caskey (c. 1803–1867) may have been the Isaiah Casky recorded in the 1860 census of Cumberland Township, Adams County, Pennsylvania. The census listed him as a 57-year-old day laborer born in Pennsylvania, in dwelling 487, family 544, with Anna M. and Sarah J. Casky. A cemetery reference for Diana Anna Caskey Sandow lists a father named Isaiah Caskey, 1803–1867, and a derivative genealogy lead connects Caskey and Sandoe families in Cumberland Township, but the identification remains only possible.
Death Year: 1867
Age in 1860: 57
Sex: M
Race: W
Birthplace: Pennsylvania
Township: Cumberland
Dwelling Number: 487
Family Number: 544
Identification Status: Possible
Confidence Level: Possible
Evidence Strength: Moderate Circumstantial